The K-pop industry is no stranger to legal battles, but the recent court decision against NewJeans has sparked intense debate among fans and the general public.
The controversy stems from the group’s attempt to break away from their label, ADOR, and the backlash they received for their comments about Korea’s entertainment system.
The Court’s Decision and Its Impact
On March 22, 2025, the court ruled in favor of ADOR, preventing NewJeans (now referred to as NJZ) from proceeding with any further activities. This decision came after the group unilaterally terminated their contract in November 2024, citing unfair treatment and workplace harassment — claims that ADOR denied.
The ruling means NewJeans cannot release music or perform without ADOR’s involvement. Despite this, the members expressed their disappointment and determination to fight back. In an interview with TIME, they stated,
“Maybe this is just the current reality in Korea. But that’s exactly why we believe change and growth are necessary.”
However, their words have not sat well with the Korean public. Here's how the general Korean public reacted.
Netizens React: Disappointment and Frustration
NewJeans’ remarks about Korea and the legal system have led to widespread criticism. Many South Korean netizens feel the group is being ungrateful, given the opportunities they received through the K-pop system.
One popular comment reads, “They used the Korean K-pop system, a Korean company, and gained success in Korea. Yet now they criticize the same system that gave them fame and money? That’s hypocritical.”
Another user pointed out, “This whole fight will only make contracts stricter for future idols. Instead of helping others, they’re making it harder for everyone.”
Some international fans support NewJeans, believing they are standing up for themselves. However, even within the global fandom, many are questioning their approach.
“They seem misguided and too young to fully understand the corporate world,” one fan noted.
Min Hee Jin’s Role and More Court Rulings
The controversy extends beyond NewJeans’ comments. The court also addressed allegations against ADOR’s CEO, Min Hee Jin. She reportedly admitted to assaulting an employee, raising further questions about the internal issues within the company.
While NewJeans’ legal battle continues, the stakes are high. If they lose the upcoming contract dispute hearing in April, they could face penalties of up to 620 billion KRW (about $423.6 million).
Our Thoughts
The situation is complex, with strong opinions on both sides. NewJeans undeniably benefited from the K-pop system, and their criticism of Korea has led to a significant backlash. At the same time, the ongoing legal dispute highlights deeper issues in the industry, such as idol contracts and workplace treatment.
Whether NewJeans is making a bold move for change or acting impulsively remains a topic of debate. What’s certain is that their future in the industry is now more uncertain than ever.
As the case unfolds, we’ll continue to follow the updates and reactions.
Do you think NewJeans’ actions will change the industry for the better or worse? Let us know your thoughts in the comments!
Comments